Introduction
What does it mean to be you? Are you always the same you? How do you know you are you? Can anyone else be you?
Understanding the nuances between identity and identifiers is crucial in comprehending the intricacies of human existence. While identity constitutes the core essence of an individual, identifiers serve as the external manifestations used to distinguish and categorize individuals within society.
While the distinction between identity and identifiers may not be entirely original, I offer my perspective through a breakdown of these concepts, drawing on and contrasting multiple related ideas
Like many of my ideas, this separation of identity and identifier has been influenced by everything I have read and heard on the subject, combined with conversations and, most recently, I was able to put the base idea into words in an AiR WhatsApp channel.
Upon doing so, we had a look to find out if there was anyone else who had described an identity vs identifier split, and indeed there was. I knew it was somewhat similar to John Locke’s person vs man description123, however, it seems the idea has been fleshed out before me. I have yet to fully read their take on the identity vs identifier split, but I will endeavor to do so after completing my writing.
Defining Identity and Identifiers
Identity
Identity, at its essence, encapsulates the amalgamation of characteristics, beliefs, and values that define an individual’s sense of self. It encompasses the intricate tapestry of experiences, cultural influences, and personal convictions that shape one’s perception of who they are.
Internal vs External Identity
Whilst Identity is mostly an internal thing about the way we see the self, people will also assign an identity to us based on their perceptions. We may even ‘put on’ a specific set of characteristics in the hope our external identity is perceived in a certain way.
Consider how you might present yourself differently at work, or around certain friends or family members. Perhaps you are louder in some situations or polite in others.
Whilst the behaviours we preset could change by situation, much of our external identity will be based on identifiers rather than actual identity characteristics.
The perception of others, based on our external representation, can feed back into how we see ourselves. Both negative and positive statements can serve as an influence for the internal self which in turn might be represented in changes in behavior or external presentation.
The Continuation of Identity
Our internal identity might feel fixed, though as we learn and grow there are key characteristics that change within. If we were to compare ourselves, or perhaps our ‘selfs’, now to the self we had when we were 5, there is a big difference.
One of the questions about identity is if we are the same person1 with all those changes, think ‘Ship of Theseus’2 -Just as replacing each plank of a ship over time raises questions about whether it remains the same ship, changes in our beliefs, habits, and relationships challenge our sense of continuity. As such, I tend to think that part of our ‘self’ is in flux. We might have a continuation of memory and awareness that makes us still feel like the same self but the self, or at least part of it, has evolved.
With our memory intact, are we still the same if we lose an arm, or change our style? Is memory alone enough to say we are the same self?
Identifiers
Conversely, identifiers are the external attributes or characteristics used by others to recognize and classify individuals. These can range from physical traits, like being left or right-handed, our hairstyle, the colour of our eyes, etc. to societal labels, such as gender*, ethnicity, or profession. We could even have our government IDs, National Insurance/Social Security Number, Birthday etc. Essentially, matters of fact about our person, rather than the person itself.
*Gender is slightly more complicated here as our gender identity can conflict with gender assignment (which is usually based on anatomical presentation). However, I have included it as an identifier as people will identify one’s gender based on physical appearance and demonstrated behaviours.3
The Influence of Identifiers on Identity
Identifiers play a pivotal role in shaping an individual’s perception of their own identity. From a young age, societal norms and cultural expectations imbue us with identifiers that contribute to our understanding of self. For instance, being labelled as “intelligent” or “athletic” can significantly impact how we view ourselves and interact with the world around us. Similarly, identifiers such as race or gender can influence societal perceptions and treatment, subsequently shaping our self-image.
Consider someone who is labeled as shy or introverted. Perhaps they are not inherently shy but rather quiet and observant. This label might negatively impact their self-perception, leading them to believe they lack confidence, or it could push them to prove the label wrong, shaping their behavior in unexpected ways.
The Relationship Between Identity and Identifiers

The relationship between identity and identifiers is dynamic and reciprocal. While identifiers can influence our perception of identity, our sense of self also influences the identifiers we adopt. For example, individuals who identify strongly with a particular subculture may adopt specific clothing styles or mannerisms to outwardly express their affiliation. This interplay highlights the symbiotic relationship between internal identity and external identifiers.
Identity Conflicts
There are times we feel in conflict with our identity. This can be because we have changed over time, that we were masking our true identity, or that some of our identity was hidden even from ourselves. There are also conflicts between the expectations others have of our identity and the way we see ourselves.
Can Identifiers be Identity/Part of your Identity?

With the symbiotic relationship between certain external aspects of our identity, we could say that some identifiers are part of our identity. Other things might have less influence over our identity. You might be bald, or have a big nose, and whilst these aspects might be used to identify you, and could have an impact on your self-esteem, they wouldn’t usually be part of your identity.
Identical Identity
What does it mean for something to be identical to something else?
This can be broken down into two key components, numerical and qualitative.
Numerical Identity
Numerical identity is tied to the law of identity, A = A. A light switch, at any given moment in time, is a light switch. A ball is not a light switch.
A key example here can be provided by looking into the world of fantasy. Consider Clark Kent and Superman – they are one and the same. They are numerically Identical. Clark Kent is Superman.
If I lose my phone, and 3 weeks later it is given to me, it is numerically the same phone. If, however, I buy the same make and model – it is not numerically the same phone.
In short, numerical identity is about the concrete substance rather than ideas.
Qualitative Identity
Qualitative Identity, however, differs in that it is about properties. Think of set theory4 – Everything in the same set has the same (or enough) properties to conclude they are qualitatively identical. Consider cars, they all have a particular set of qualities that make them cars. Further to this, we could own the “same” car – but that doesn’t mean that we are sharing the same car, it means we have the same make and model.
Identical twins are a prime example here – they not only exist in the set of humans but are nearly physically and biologically identical in every way – yet they are not numerically the same. They are (almost) qualitatively identical.
To refer back to my lost phone example, buying the same make and model is qualitatively the same.
Self-Identity is it Numerical or Qualitative?
To tie this back into the continuation of identity – I am numerically identical to 5-year-old me, the me I present at work, the me around certain family members. But, I am not qualitatively identical in those scenarios.
Similarly, if I go to a gig in a particular attire, my external identity is that of the group listening to that music. In this scenario, you could say I am (almost) qualitatively identical, at least at a high level to the other attendees.
Therefore, we could summarise that the internal identity is numerical and external could fit in the realms of qualitative.
What would you say about the Ship of Theseus though? Is it numerically identical? Is it Qualitatively Identical? Is it both or neither?
What about if your memory gets wiped and you have to start over, learning everything again? Are you the same numerically or qualitatively?
Philosophical Perspectives
Philosophers have long grappled with questions surrounding personal identity and the role of identifiers in shaping selfhood. John Locke, in his work on personal identity1, proposed the concept of the “person” versus the “man.” He argued that personal identity is rooted in consciousness and self-awareness rather than physical attributes or characteristics. This distinction underscores the philosophical debate surrounding the nature of identity and its relationship to external identifiers.
Other examples to note are the Ship of Theseus2, Derek Parfit’s “bundle theory”56 questioning the nature of personal identity, the concept of “self” in existentialism7 (particularly Jean-Paul Sartre)8910, and discussions around the relationship between physical body and mental states in identity persistence.
Locke’s Ideas on Personal Identity
John Locke emphasized memory as central to personal identity. Locke argued that our personal identity is tied to our ability to remember past experiences. For example, if you recall being a child learning to ride a bike, that memory connects your past and present self, reinforcing your sense of identity over time. Without memory, Locke suggests, we would lack a continuous sense of self.
Parfit’s Bundle Theory
Parfit challenged the notion of a fixed self, proposing instead that we are a collection of experiences and psychological connections.
Imagine a bundle of sticks tied together to form a single unit. Each stick represents an aspect of your experiences, beliefs, and memories. Together, they create what we perceive as ‘self,’ but if you remove or change a few sticks, is it still the same bundle? Parfit’s theory suggests there’s no fixed core identity, only the interplay of these parts.
Exploring Examples
Examining real-world examples further elucidates the complex interplay between identity and identifiers. From the adoption of cultural customs to the expression of personal beliefs, individuals navigate a myriad of identifiers that both shape and reflect their sense of self. Whether it’s through artistic expression, religious affiliation, or political ideology, individuals use identifiers as a means of self-expression and social belonging.
We can see this in music; when fans of a band wear its merchandise, they signal their connection to that subculture, turning an external identifier into a badge of identity. Fans of a particular type of media will wear t-shirts or even cosplay those characters – again this turns the external expression into a badge of identity. Perhaps new hobbies are taken up because the in-group all do a certain thing. All of this and more serves to bring people closer together.
The flip side of this is that, at times, people can feel left out for not having the same expression. This could be for a multitude of reasons, from finances to self-esteem, and, at times, can create exclusive cliques.
Next time you are in a crowd, take note of the various groups of people, and other individuals that might fit the parameters of that group.
Practical Applications
Understanding the distinction between identity and identifiers has practical implications for personal development and social interaction. By recognizing the influence of external identifiers on our sense of self, individuals can cultivate a deeper understanding of their own identity and navigate societal expectations more consciously. Moreover, acknowledging the fluid nature of identity allows for greater flexibility in self-expression and interpersonal relationships.
The hope is, that once one has gained this understanding we can work to reduce biases, stereotypes, and expectations whilst fostering more inclusive environments for everyone.
Personal Development and Self-Understanding
Understanding the distinction between identity and identifiers can help individuals separate their self-worth from external labels. For example, someone labeled as ‘lazy’ in school might later realize they simply learn differently and excel in creative environments, reshaping their self-perception and confidence.
Workplace Dynamics
In the workplace, recognizing how identifiers influence identity can improve inclusivity. For instance, a manager might label an employee as ‘quiet’ and assume they lack leadership potential. By focusing instead on the employee’s skills and aspirations, the manager might uncover leadership qualities that redefine the employee’s role and self-identity.
Cultural or Social Understanding
In multicultural settings, identifiers like ethnicity or religion can shape how others perceive individuals. Recognizing these influences can foster empathy and reduce stereotyping, encouraging people to see beyond labels to the complex identities within.
Challenges and Considerations
However, navigating the complexities of identity and identifiers is not without its challenges. The fluidity of identity can present difficulties in self-definition, particularly in the face of societal expectations and cultural norms. Moreover, the use of identifiers as a means of categorization can perpetuate stereotypes and marginalize certain groups within society. Addressing these challenges requires a nuanced understanding of identity and a commitment to fostering inclusivity11 and acceptance.
Labeling and Stereotyping
Assigning labels can sometimes lead to harmful stereotyping. For example, a child labeled as ‘troublemaker’ might internalize this identity, leading to behavioral problems that align with the label. Understanding this dynamic can help parents and educators use more constructive identifiers.
Technology and Identity
In an era of digital identities, social media platforms often assign us identities through algorithms, categorizing us by our interests or behaviors. This can lead to echo chambers, where people’s sense of self is shaped and reinforced by what they are shown online.
Ethical Representation
When using identifiers in research or public policy, it’s crucial to ensure they accurately reflect the group they represent. For instance, defining someone solely by their income level or education might miss nuances that are essential for creating effective, equitable policies.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the distinction between identity and identifiers is essential in comprehending the multifaceted nature of human selfhood. By recognizing the influence of external identifiers on our sense of identity and vice versa, individuals can navigate the complexities of self-expression and interpersonal relationships more effectively. Embracing the fluidity of identity and challenging societal norms allows for greater authenticity and empowerment in one’s journey of self-discovery.
I hope, dear reader, that I have given you something to ponder. Having read the article, do you still feel the same about who YOU are? Do you still answer the questions asked at the start in the same way? “What does it mean to be you? Are you always the same you? How do you know you are you? Can anyone else be you?”
Some questions to think about:
- How do societal norms influence our sense of identity? How do they influence you?
Societal norms play a significant role in shaping our perception of self by providing frameworks for acceptable behavior and identity markers. How do these influence you? - Can identifiers change over time? What Identifiers have you changed?
Yes, identifiers are not fixed and can evolve as individuals grow, learn, and adapt to new experiences and circumstances. What identifiers have you changed? - What role do cultural identifiers play in shaping identity? What influence have these had on you? Do they still influence you?
Cultural identifiers, such as language, customs, and traditions, contribute to our sense of belonging and help define our cultural identity. What influence have these had on you? Do they still influence you? - Are there ethical implications associated with the use of identifiers?
Yes, the use of identifiers can have ethical implications, particularly when they reinforce stereotypes or lead to discrimination and marginalization. Have you ever used identifiers in this way? Have you misgendered someone? Do you make an effort to be ethical with the use of identifiers? - How can individuals cultivate a more authentic sense of identity?
Cultivating authenticity involves self-reflection, introspection, and embracing the complexities of one’s identity beyond external labels and identifiers. What have you done to become a more authentic self?
References
- Locke on Personal Identity (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) ↩︎
- Ship of Theseus | Definition, Examples, & Solutions | Britannica ↩︎
- Sex Cells and Gender Tells ↩︎
- Set Theory: The Fundamentals ↩︎
- Personal Identity (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) ↩︎
- Derek Parfit, Divided Minds and the Nature of Persons – PhilPapers ↩︎
- Existentialism (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) ↩︎
- Jean-Paul Sartre’s Concept of the Other – PHILO-notes ↩︎
- Sartre, Jean Paul: Existentialism | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy ↩︎
- Jean-Paul Sartre (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) ↩︎
- Inclusion and Diversity ↩︎

I’m Joe. I write under the name Davidian, not only because it is a Machine Head song I enjoy but because it was a game character I used to role-play that was always looking to better himself.
This is one of many things I hope to do with Answers In Reason.
I run our Twitter and IG accounts, as well as share responsibility for our FB group and page, and maintain the site, whilst writing articles, DJing, Podcasting (and producing), keeping fit and more.
Feel free to read a more detailed bio here: https://www.answers-in-reason.com/about/authors/4/
You can find my main social links here:
Twitter(Air): https://twitter.com/answersinreason
Twitter(ADHD): https://twitter.com/Davidian_ADHD
TikTok (AiR): https://www.tiktok.com/@answersinreason
TikTok (ADHD): https://www.tiktok.com/@adultadhdjourney
Ask me a question on Wisdom: https://app.wisdom.audio/ask/0be23c32-0fac-4d8f-bf68-671d9c8a3b95


