Are we responsible for how others act based on what we say? Can we control what others think and feel? How does power dynamics and bias fit into this?
Introduction
It’s quite common to hear people absolve themselves of responsibility when they’ve upset another, or influenced someone to take an action that has resulted in harm. Some might go as far as to say they are not responsible for their opinions, but then, who is?
In this article, I consider the meanings of action, expression, opinion, responsibility, accountability, and consequences, as well as broaching topics such as epistemic responsibility and providing arguments both in conversational and logical form.
Contents (click to read more)
Actions
To act, or take action, is to do something. It is a process actively undertaken.
Actions can be split into two main categories, physical and mental. These can be broken down into subsets, but for this article we can consider these two as they are.
Physical Action

When most consider actions, they think of physical actions1. These actions result in some external impact to the world around them. For example, kicking a ball or throwing a punch.
Communication is also a physical action. One actively converts their mental processing to have a physical presence with something like speech or email.

Expression, in this sense, is the act of saying what you think or showing how you feel using words or action. So speaking, a form of communication, is a form of expression.
Most of our physical actions are a result of conscious processing, but many happen automatically. Consider stubbing your toe or burning your hand on a stove and the processes that immediately follow.
Mental Action
Mental actions2 are those that reside within our mind, thinking, deciding, and so on.
We have some level of agency3 in what we think, and if we act on our thoughts.
Automatic Processes
There also exists a realm of mental action that we have little to no control over. Our automatic processes, like breathing and our heart beating, for example. We can consciously override them when awake, but these usually function without the need to actively control them.
Reactions are another sort of automatic process we have little control over – someone steps on our toe and we might make a noise and step away, the pain might even involve a violent or angry response. Whilst the act of stepping away is a physical one, the reaction is an automatic process that results in a physical automatic process.
Dreams
Dreams are another thing that we have little control over, and whilst you can train your mind to have more conscious control over your dreams, they are still an unconscious process.
Emotions
Our emotions are not directly controlled by us either, we can do work to improve our mental and emotional responses, but these are ultimately an unconscious process.
We cannot control how we feel in a flip of the switch sense, but we can have some control over how we react based on how we feel, and we can actively do things that will make us feel a certain way.
Cognitive/Unconscious Bias
Cognitive4 or unconscious5 biases are essentially brain energy saving devices that save us from reanalysing the entire world when questions are asked like “do you like steak?” Or “fancy listening to drum and bass?” – however, there exists a seedy undertow to these biases that we need to try and make ourselves aware of.
We are naturally inclined to favour those more like us, so we might form biases based on sex, race, gender and other qualities as we develop. We might also attribute certain behaviours to a gender, such as women being more nurturing or men being more analytical.
Whilst these biases might not be wrong, it is important to be aware of them when making decisions.
An applicant for a childcare job isn’t automatically a better candidate just because they are female, an applicant for a programming job isn’t automatically better because they are male.
I mention these two fields because they are predominantly female and male dominated, respectively.
Summary of Mental Actions
Whilst our mental processes are not physical actions in themselves, they can influence our physical actions, sometimes unknowingly – which is why it is important to be aware of unconscious bias as we need to implement checks to see if our decisions have been affected by them.
Now that we’ve established how our thoughts influence actions, let’s examine how responsibility fits into this picture.
Responsibility
“Taking responsibility means acknowledging and accepting accountability for one’s actions, decisions, and their consequences, whether positive or negative. It involves being honest about your role in a situation and being willing to face the outcomes, both good and bad.”
Responsibility6 can relate to tasks we are expected to perform or any duties, e.g. a colleague is responsible for running the 9 am reports, or a parent has the duty of care of their children.
Part of being responsible is accepting accountability – which we will cover in a moment.
So how does responsibility relate to opinions?
Responsibility and Opinions
There are, at least, two types of responsibility that relate to opinions.
The first, is the responsibility mentioned in the quote above. When we take action based on our opinion, or express an opinion, we initiate a causal chain of events. Actions have consequences. To be responsible we have to accept accountability.
Even if someone doesn’t hold you responsible or accountable, you still have some responsibility, you’re just free from anything coming back at you.
The other type of responsibility is epistemic responsibility789.
Below are two arguments I’ve put together in logical form to justify responsibility further. If you want to skip this section and proceed to accountability, click here.
Deductive Argument: The Responsibility for the Expression of Opinion
P1. Expression is an action.
P2. Communication is a form of expression.
C1. Therefore, communication is an action.
P3. Expressing an opinion means to communicate an opinion.
C2. Therefore, expressing an opinion is an action.
P4. Actions have consequences.
P5. Agency gives us some level of responsibility for our actions.
C3. Therefore, agency makes us responsible for our actions and the consequences that follow.
P6. Since expressing an opinion is an action (C2), it has consequences (P4).
P7. The act of expression requires agency.
C4. Therefore, the agent is responsible for expressing an opinion, and the consequences that follow.
To be clear, the agent is not wholly responsible for another person’s actions, they also have agency, however, power dynamics and other considerations must be reflected upon to be able to infer level of responsibility.

Deductive Argument: Our Epistemic Responsibility for Opinions

Whilst an opinion isn’t a physical action, it’s still a mental action, but if you want to call mental actions not-actions, that’s fine, I’ll call country music not-music and be equally wrong.
However, we are still responsible for our opinions in a different sense…
P1. Holding an opinion implies having a belief.
P2. Having a belief involves a commitment to its truth.
C1. Therefore, holding an opinion involves a commitment to its truth.
P3. Epistemic responsibility refers to the obligation to ensure our beliefs are justified and well-founded.
P4. If we are committed to the truth of our opinions, we have an obligation to justify them. (At least to ourselves)
C2. Therefore, holding an opinion entails epistemic responsibility.
P5. Justifying our opinions requires us to evaluate evidence, consider alternative perspectives, and be open to revision.
P6. An epistemically responsible person seeks to avoid spreading misinformation and contributing to ignorance.
C3. Therefore, holding an opinion responsibly requires us to engage in practices that promote knowledge and understanding.
P7. Failing to justify our opinions or ignoring evidence results in epistemic irresponsibility.
C4. Therefore, individuals are epistemically responsible for their opinions and the impact they have on knowledge and discourse.
So, we are both responsible for ensuring our opinions are based on good information and the consequences of expressing them. But how does accountability fit into this?
Accountability
Accountability, on the other hand, means being answerable for the outcome of those responsibilities. It focuses on ownership and ensuring that tasks are carried out effectively. Accountability is often individual, you can delegate responsibility but not accountability. For instance, a manager might be accountable for the overall success of a project, even though different team members are responsible for various parts. The manager, in turn, can hold the team members accountable for the parts they are responsible for.
Responsibility and accountability exist independently of recognition; they remain intact, even when unseen or unacknowledged by others.
Being responsible or accountable is often tied to personal integrity, which exists independent of observation. Integrity means being true to one’s values, even when no one is watching.
Many ethical theories suggest that certain obligations are universal and don’t depend on others holding us accountable. For example, Kantian ethics proposes that moral duties are absolute and not conditional on recognition by others.
Consequence
“We are free to choose our actions, but we are not free to choose the consequences of those actions.”
Stephen R. Covey
Our mental processes can affect the way we act externally. Consider something evoking the emotion of anger, we might become snappy, violent, or perhaps we become negative and more prone to tell people no.
We may not have much agency over the way we feel, but we do have agency over the way we act on how we feel. If we recognise we are in a particular state, we can try to delay interactions until we are in a better frame of mind.
If we act in anger, there are potential consequences. Perhaps we make someone scared or less likely to listen. Perhaps we don’t listen and ignore some salient advice or turn down something that could have had a positive impact on us. We could engage recklessly in a dangerous venture.
We may not have been responsible for the way we felt, and that could have influenced different behaviours to how we normally act, but we are still in control of our actions.
There are, as with most things, a few exceptions to the rule – states like blind rage or temporary insanity, where we momentarily lose control and become a wholly reactive emotional being.
Actions and Consequences
If, for now, we pause thought on our underlying states and consider our actions and consequences they could have on another being.
Violence
One of the simplest examples of action and consequence is violent behaviour. Whilst we could go into the types of violence, let’s keep it simple and focus on what most people think when they hear the word violence, physical violence.
Let’s say we punch someone on the nose.
They suffer pain, their nose might bleed, and possibly even a break.
There could be immediate subsequent consequences like them fighting back, or someone stepping in to protect them, but there can also be a sequence of events initiated such as them seeking legal advice, you being arrested and fined or given jail time, you could lose your job, friends and all sorts.
The consequences are not limited to this paradigm, but we could spend days on the ifs, buts and little worlds, suffice it to say, your actions can create a chain of events or causal chain1011.
“At its most basic, a causal chain is an ordered sequence of events linking the causes of a problem with its effects”
IW:LEARN | Manuals -> TDA/SAP Methodology -> 3.9 – Causal Chain Analysis -> What is causal chain analysis?
Actions that follow from your actions mean you share responsibility, with diminishing returns, to each subsequent action.
“A causal chain is repeatedly described as a sequence of events for which one event in a chain causes the next.”
A Causal Theory of Knowing – Wikipedia
You might be asking, “what if I was provoked” and we could question if your violence was permissible given differing circumstances – and whilst I love an ethics discussion, that isn’t the focus of this article. Justified or not, you bear some responsibility for the consequences and subsequent actions.
Why am I responsible?
Let’s say you derail a train, you wicked being you.
This causes many deaths and injuries.
One child loses their parents in this disaster.
Their parents were wonderful, and were going to send them to the best school, enroll them in the acting program they wanted to go into and set them up for life.
Without their parents, their care fell to a selfish, greedy aunt who kept all the inheritance for themselves, barely even fed the child, and they didn’t get to go to any of the programs and ventures they were supposed to.
Silo’d, sure, you’re not responsible for how that aunt acted, but would that child have been in that situation had you not detailed the train?
You see, there is a causal link between the events that wouldn’t have been there had you not derailed that train. You might not be directly responsible for the child’s misfortune, but you played a part in creating that circumstance.
It should be noted that good actions don’t always lead to good consequences and bad don’t always lead to bad.
The key difference here is intent; while you share responsibility through the causal chain, consequences aren’t the only factor.
At the risk of diverting further, consider being jealous of and disliking a colleague, you get them fired. They go on to start their own company and become a millionaire. You do share some responsibility in creating the situation that led them to their fortune, but your intent was to do them harm. It should be obvious how that is qualitatively different to believing in someone, and providing them start-up cash to get their business going.
Communication
“We’re not responsible for what we say, only what we do”
- Paraphrased from a twitter conversation
There are some who believe they can say what they like and are totally free from all consequences. Some make claims of freedom of speech12, but that isn’t really what it’s about.
“Everyone has the right to freedom of expression. This right shall include freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas without interference by public authority and regardless of frontiers.”
This does not mean you’re not responsible, just that there should be no interference from public authority, however, this is then qualified by
“The exercise of these freedoms, since it carries with it duties and responsibilities, may be subject to such formalities, conditions, restrictions or penalties as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society, in the interests of national security, territorial disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, for the protection of the reputation or rights of others, for preventing the disclosure of information received in confidence, or for maintaining the authority and impartiality of the judiciary.”
Which basically means there are some circumstances where freedom of speech is limited, and if you fail to adhere to certain conditions, there could be consequences.
It should be noted that article 10 point 2 notes that these freedoms carry duties and responsibilities, the freedom of expression does not free us from those.
“If I express an opinion, it’s not up to me what people do with that, they could ignore me”

Some feel that because they can’t control what others do, they can say what they like and are free of the consequences.
Let’s examine a few situations
The Boss: Example 1
A boss tells an employee that they will lose their job if they sleep with them.
The employee, worried for their job, sleeps with their boss, even though they don’t want to.
Is their boss responsible?
The employee didn’t have to listen to them.
Other than the fact that this is a form of rape and there are now protections in place for this sort of behaviour, we can see how the boss is using their power and treating the employee as an object.
Even if the employee didn’t sleep with the boss, it could cause them serious stress and anxiety – this could affect performance and give the boss grounds to sack the employee.
The Haircut: Example 2
What about if I hold the opinion my wife’s new haircut is lovely?
What’s more, I express that opinion to her and it makes her happy.
Do I have any responsibility in my wife’s happiness?
She might not have cared if I didn’t say anything (yeah right 😜) but her response is an emotional one that was a direct cause of my words. The chain might stop there, or she might go to work in a better mood, have a better day, be more productive and so on.
You see, our words can and do have impact on others. We can’t control how we or others feel in a physical pressing of buttons sense, but our words can flick proverbial switches in anothers mind and cause them to have an emotional response.
In fact, they can do a lot more than that too.
Admiration: Example 3
Perhaps you have a friend that looks up to you, they respect your knowledge and believe what you say without question.
They get a cancer diagnosis and you tell them not to get chemo and to go get a crystal healing.
Unfortunately, they believe you and they end up having a long, painful, miserable death.
Sure, they didn’t have to listen to you, but do you not share any responsibility for their actions? Would they have stuck to modern medicine had you not advised against it?
Power Dynamic: A common theme
What should be clear from all 3 examples here is the power dynamic.
A power dynamic refers to the imbalance of influence between individuals, where one party has more control, authority, or social weight than the other.
The boss is simple, they have authority over the employee.
The friend, again this should be fairly obvious, their admiration gives you a form of power over them.
The wife – well, power dynamics in a relationship are a bit more complex, but to try and keep it simple: This is the being chosen to partner with for the rest of one’s life. Their opinion, assuming all is well in the marriage, will mean a lot to you – and vice versa.
In all the examples, I think we’d agree the words expressed have more impact from those people than if it came from some random person on the internet or in the street – this is mostly to do with the power dynamic and rapport.
The Causal Chain, Power Dynamic and Rapport
What makes you partly responsible is your part in the causal chain, especially if your actions chain the course of events with your words.
Your responsibility is also increased based on the power you hold over someone. Therefore, someone in the spotlight that’s charismatic and influential has more responsibility to choose their words carefully and fact check their information than the ‘average Joe’, but that doesn’t negate the average Joe’s responsibility either.
When celebrities, politicians, and others with a big reach spread misinformation, they can potentially cause much more harm than you or I.
Whether it’s an expert stepping out of their lain like an evolutionary biologist spreading false history or bad plumbing advice, or billionaires like Musk with no medical training spreading vaccines misinformation, or a politician working people up into a frenzy and causing a riot with false claims of stolen elections, we can see how words have influence others and can lead to harm being caused.
Everyone’s entitled to an opinion, but we should be careful how we share it and who we share it with.
What if no one holds me responsible?

There’s an odd attitude sometimes present that if you’re not held responsible or accountable then you’re not responsible.
This is a similar attitude to “it’s not a crime if you don’t get caught” – but for a simple example:
You break a window
No one saw
No one will punish you
Yet without your actions, no window would be broken.
The same can be said for an expression of opinion.
You express an opinion
This leads to people ignoring medical advice and dying
No one holds you responsible
Yet without your actions, those people would not have ignored medical advice.
The idea that you need some sort of external arbiter and punishment is damaging in itself, as it lets people absolve themselves of their responsibility and can lead to careless or intentionally negative behaviours.
Why do so many have this attitude though?
I think many of us are not truly taught what it means to be responsible, nor taught to spend time reflecting inwards about our thoughts and actions.
I also think it is a failing of schools and guardians. We teach our kids to avoid consequences rather than spending the time making them understand the ethical implications of their behaviours.
When you combine that with how some rules are just totally illogical and there is no justification for them, kids rebel, or at least learn to ignore the rule and then learn to do it in a way that avoids getting caught so there’s no consequences and voila, they don’t feel any responsibility.
Some folks are also taught there is this all powerful being watching them all the time and that’s why they have to behave, and whilst most whom lose that belief maintain or even improve their moral standing, some might go the other way and feel like if there’s no ultimate arbiter, there’s no reason to act responsibly.
Ethics, critical thinking and epistemic responsibility really need to be part of the school curriculum.
Summary
If nothing else, I hope the key parts of this article are at least understood.
- Expression is an action.
- Actions have consequences.
- We are responsible for our actions and consequences.
- Expressing an opinion in an action, and therefore has consequences.
- We are responsible, at least in part, for the consequences of expressing an opinion.
Personal Statement
Whilst I am aware of the above and believe it to be the case, I am far from an excellent communicator. Sometimes I fall flat on my face and fail to effectively get my point across. Online, I can sometimes get frustrated and respond poorly. I’m also an emotional being with lots going on in my head constantly. My face, body, tone, and phrasing choice can all make someone infer things I’m not saying.. perhaps they feel like I hate them or am at least upset with them. Usually, this will be unrelated to anything in the current conversation but as it’s something hanging over me it comes out in my words, posture, and facial expression. It would be too easy to say that I’m not responsible for the person taking me this way, especially if they are someone that knows me well, but that is not the case. My expression is directly responsible for that person’s thoughts, and whilst they too have agency, simply stating “they should know better” doesn’t suffice. I should also know better, and make more effort to separate what’s going on in my head and the situation I am present in. Thus, I share responsibility in the situation I created with my behaviour, even if I wasn’t fully aware of how I was presenting myself.
References
- The Epistemology of Physical Action | Agency and Self-Awareness: Issues in Philosophy and Psychology | Oxford Academic ↩︎
- Mental Actions – Bibliography – PhilPapers ↩︎
- Agency (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) ↩︎
- What Is Cognitive Bias? Types & Examples ↩︎
- Unconscious bias | Royal College of Nursing ↩︎
- The Importance of Taking Responsibility: Building Trust and Respect ↩︎
- Responsibility: The Epistemic Condition | Oxford Academic ↩︎
- Epistemic Responsibility 1 : International Journal of Philosophical Studies: Vol 16 , No 2 ↩︎
- Intellectual responsibility – Wikipedia ↩︎
- IW:LEARN | Manuals -> TDA/SAP Methodology -> 3.9 – Causal Chain Analysis -> What is causal chain analysis? ↩︎
- A Causal Theory of Knowing – Wikipedia ↩︎
- Article 10: Freedom of expression | EHRC ↩︎
Enjoy the Article? You might also like:
- Can a concept be objective?

- Words, Actions, and the Web of Responsibility



- Category Errors and Meaningless Propositions: Why Bricks Can’t Be Happy.



- Types of Non-Theism



- Labels and Referents: Navigating the Maze of Language





I’m Joe. I write under the name Davidian, not only because it is a Machine Head song I enjoy but because it was a game character I used to role-play that was always looking to better himself.
This is one of many things I hope to do with Answers In Reason.
I run our Twitter and IG accounts, as well as share responsibility for our FB group and page, and maintain the site, whilst writing articles, DJing, Podcasting (and producing), keeping fit and more.
Feel free to read a more detailed bio here: https://www.answers-in-reason.com/about/authors/4/
You can find my main social links here:
Twitter(Air): https://twitter.com/answersinreason
Twitter(ADHD): https://twitter.com/Davidian_ADHD
TikTok (AiR): https://www.tiktok.com/@answersinreason
TikTok (ADHD): https://www.tiktok.com/@adultadhdjourney
Ask me a question on Wisdom: https://app.wisdom.audio/ask/0be23c32-0fac-4d8f-bf68-671d9c8a3b95











