Tonight we discuss thought experiments, how they might be answered through different moral theories, and how context might change folks’ answers.
We will start with the Trolley Problem, and if we run out of time will cover the rest in a future episode, such as the experience machine or doctor problem.
Most people are at the very least aware of the trolley problem via memes across the internet and there are a variety of different thoughts on it. The basic trolley problem has a trolley/tram/train heading towards 5 folks tied to the tracks. The track next to it has one person tied to it. You are standing next to a lever that can switch the tracks saving those 5 people, but in doing so it will cause the one person to die who is tied to the other track. What do you do?
- Saving the many outweighs the needs of the few.
- Pulling the lever means you are responsible for that person’s death whereas you were not responsible for tieing folks to the tracks, therefore pulling the lever is immoral as you cause the death.
- Once aware of any situation you become a moral agent, and therefore inaction is a form of action because you could have saved 5 people
- A number of people try to not answer the question saying they would stop the trolley by some other means or something which is not part of the hypothetical.
How various moral theories would answer it
- Consequentialist (e.g. Act Utilitarianism or Welfarism)
- Deontological (e.g. Kantianism, or Rule Utilitarianism)
- Virtue Ethics
Adding Context to the Trolley Problem
When we consider the trolley problem, it is considered as a blank template, with all the lives counting as equal, no negative consequences (except the obvious) from saving them etc. For example, the 5 people are not considered mass murders, and saving them would do more harm than good. Therefore the only real objective means of deciding what happens is using mathematics, and 5 is better than 1 based on an equal value system. Some still wouldn’t pull the lever as they feel they are actively responsible for death rather than being passively responsible for 5.
What happens then if we add context? If the 5 are the Trumps, and the 1 is someone who is going to cure cancer, for example, we might suddenly change our mind on how we are going to act. Some might argue that there is more chance of getting bad people in the 5, but this could be flipped and there is also more chance of good people being in the 5 too. So here we will go through a number of different trolley problem memes to see how we might act in this situation.
There are other thought experiments as well, which we will mention, and in fact we go in to detail about the experience machine!
Want to Watch us Live?
You can watch us live on:
- YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/c/Answers-in-reason
- Twitch: http://twitch.tv/u/davidiantwitchyballs
- Twitter: https://twitter.com/answersinreason
The Published SciPhi Show can be found in the following YouTube playlist:
Don’t have time for the longer streams? We’ve got you covered. We created a playlist of various clips and highlights from the stream. These are a combination of interesting segments, jokes and funny bits, questions from the audience and times when we stack it and think you deserve a laugh at our expense.
Fresh AiR Podcast
The Fresh AiR Podcast is still going strong and can be heard in a number of outlets.
For the full experience, we suggest the website: https://www.answers-in-reason.com/series/fresh-air/ as we provide a number of links to various resources discussed in the article, however, can be seen on a number of podcast outlets such as: iTunes | Stitcher | Google Play | Spotify | Podplayer – and we are not limited to these either, just search for Answers in Reason or Fresh AiR in your favourite podcast syndication.
Fresh AiR Videos!
Whilst the SciPhi show is quick live videos discussing relevant and current topics, with Season 3 we tried a few different things with Fresh AiR, inclusive of videos taking people through concepts.
These can be found both on the site, and in this YouTube playlist:
At Answers in Reason we provide all our content to you for free, but we do have server costs and would love to be in a position to provide you content more regularly than we do.
As such we have started a Patreon page.
Each Tier has the benefits of the previous tier plus additional benefits
Tier 1 provides basic access to the community.
Here you will see any of our private blog posts, memes, and anything else we share just to our Patreon. You also get basic access to our discord server.
Tier 2 gives early access
Before we release our articles and podcasts to the public, you get access as soon as they are produced.
Tier 3 gives enhanced access
We will give you the podcast server address with the ability to listen in to the conversation live, and message us whilst on AiR.
You will receive access to the podcasts before they have been edited. The raw show, including any faux pas, and none of the after-show additions like the soundbytes.
You will also get enhanced access on the discord server, and be allowed to join us on the SciPhi streams. (Subject to availability, we don’t want to crash the server)
And lastly, we will send you an AiR T-shirt after 3 months of membership.
Tier 4 gives pro access
As a dedicated fan, we not only give you all the above (plus free delivery on the AiR T-Shirt World Wide) and additional exclusive content but also we have a circa 30 minute interview, finding out about your life and interests, and what you hope to gain from the community.
There will also be additional gifts from time to time, clothing, mugs, etc.
Tier 5 gives the Apex of Access
You get all the previous benefits PLUS you get to suggest and cohost a topic for Fresh AiR. (The topic does have to be running with the theme of Fresh AiR, e.g. a Philosophical/Scientific angle of sorts)
Tiers may be subject to review and change in future if required, but you will always be informed in advance.