16th July 2021 Davidian 0 Comment
A proposition is a bivalent statement (or claim) that expresses a judgement or opinion. It is truth-apt and, therefore, can be true or false. A claim is an assertion something is true (or false). There’s is propositional content in a claim but they are not exactly the same thing, at least not always. What’s the difference between a proposition and a claim? A proposition can be presented without the assertion it is true or false. This would be for the... ...
19th June 2020 Davidian
AtheismBurden of ProofChristianityConversations With TheistsEvidenceHinduismIslamJustificationMisc ReligiousReligionTruth0 Comment
This post is set to examine the average theistic presentation of evidence, whether it is strong, weak, convincing, or even really evidence at all. We (atheists) often tell theists their ‘evidence’ is ‘not evidence’, and this is often incorrect. Evidence is indicative rather than completely conclusive (even if we do make conclusions off of evidence), so anything that indicates something could be true IS evidence. It doesn’t mean it is strong or convincing though. It also poses an issue when...
18th February 2020 Davidian 4 Comments
“The burden is on the claimant!”, “I only lack belief so I have no burden”, “I don’t hold a belief as that is a claim” and other phrases are touted by many fellow atheists on the internet. Is this correct, or are we missing some of the picture? This article hopes to discuss What is the burden of proof? (aka BoP) To whom does the burden of proof apply? What do we mean by claim? Before we start, I feel...
SciPhi Show Times
Tagsagnostic agnosticism Atheism Atheist belief Bible BoP burden of proof Christianity comic Critical Thinking Debate epistemology Ethics evidence Evolution Fallacies Fallacy Free will fresh air God justification life Logic misconceptions moral morality moral theory normative objective objective morality Philosophy podcast politics Psychology rationality reason religion Scepticism science sciphi subjective theism Theist truth